Thursday, October 23, 2008
Maraba
Maraba is a pretty cool little city. Not as cool as Santarem, but I like it. Its also in the Sul do Para, which is infinetely more different than Santarem in the western part of the state. The South is a whole different Para for sure.
We left on Monday and began the long drive in our convees to the south of the state. Theres been so much seen and talked about so far and I dont really know where to start, Im a little overwhlemed and without my diary nearby nor pictures its a little hard to recall everything. What I have been learning a lot about is how communities can organize against injustice, externally against the government and large landowners/interests and internally to strengthen community. Basically, what I am studying at school, anthropology=community development and social solidarity, is not useless.
Tomorrow we begin our rural homestay with the MST community south of here. Very excited.
In Maraba there isnt really too much to do, but its nice to walk around. The hotel is closeby to this amazing little açai shop. Where we eat all of our meals, and by we I mean a few friends and I, and by all I mean dinner. But its great. Very filling, and sleep-inducing. Im gonna miss the purple goo back home.
We also visited Tucurui Dam the other day. Right now, it is the fourth highest energy producing hydroelectric dam in the world. We got to hear from both the managers of Tucurui and its development plans as well as spokespersons from the communities that have been flooded due to its construction, amngst with that all of the community organizing that must take place to first for your rights against such a giant.
As much as I can miss the people back home, back at school, and all the rest, theres something to be said for just being cut off from it all. Checking my email once in 10 days is nice, to be honest. And you cant grow if you keep staying close to what is familiar. Being in my rural homestay, or maybe just Brazil in general, has taught me that. I like being cut off. I like being forced into situations here, but above all, I like being alone and on my own. I like the independence. Which is so strange for me, because usually I am afraid to be alone, and for the first real time here, I like to embrace it. I love the feeling of just going with what life throws at you and thinking about the now. Maybe it is selfish to some extent, but isnt the whole point of a semester abroad to find yourself, to find time for you, to be a little selfish?
Things are good here, and I feel secure with life in general. It means a lot to me to feel good about living in the now. As someone said to me once, "wrestling taught me that above all else, everything always works out, andd so im generally not worried about life". Well said.
Sunday, October 19, 2008
Off to the South
Today has been pretty long. I decided adamantly not to bring my suitcase for this excursion because how much of a drag/embarrasing it was last time. So this time, I'll make everyone else look bad because I'm brining my little waterproof compression bag and my backpack. That's it. The real question is...do I bring a razor and shaving cream? Because they take up a lot of room in the back pack.
Today I also realized I have reached my limit for certain portuguese phrases. I know it's not right and has no logic, but I can no longer stand hearing the phrase meu filho, my son, over and over. Everywhere. Equally as grinding on my nerves is the way Maura talks to Urso, the dog. Sweet god.
I also tried to call Dr. Tozzi today, the Health Coordinator at Projecto Saude e Alegria, but alas no avail. I'll bring his # with along our South of Para trip, but I guess I'll just need to try extra hard to get in touch with him ASAP when we return. Then again, maybe he'll check his email in the next 10 days. It's in Portuguese, so maybe that will give me some street cred.
I've been making playlists today for the long bus rides down to Maraba. It's more or less 8 hours flat in the convees. Great. Naturally I'll be somewhat anti-social for several of those hours. I currently have Don't Stop Believing by Journey stuck in my head. Actually, it always is. I'm excited to get to Maraba though. Besides all the lectures and discussions, of course, we're staying at a little hotel, but the city itself, says Diego, is a lot like Santarem in size. I loved Santarem. So I'm hoping this city is equally as cool and affords equally as many prime-chilling locations.
Tomorrow I need to wake up at 4:30 to get ready to leave. We need to be at the office by 5. And leave at 5:30 for the ferry. I'm not a morning person at all, as most of you know, so I like the idea of letting that well-known fact be an excuse to space out for several hours. It should be a good trip. I'm ready to get away from Belem and all of that for a bit. Plus, our group got much closer during the Manaus trip and now things are good. I feel like I can call up most people to hang out or something.
On a side note, Urso just walked into my room, grabbed a sock in his mouth, and left. He does this at least 4 times a week.
If I get the chance to update this in the next 10 days I will. Otherwise, expect another long picture filled entry in 10 days.
Tchau
Saturday, October 18, 2008
Suco e Acai
So. Ver-O-Peso was fun. Today felt real independent. Taking the bus was a piece of cake, asking how much things cost at the market, bartering, and so on. Plus acerola juice is always good. I also almost never got lost now on the bus. I'm learning. Today my family came back and it felt good to see them and speak lots of portuguese and feel competent. Monday we go off to southern Para and the MST. It's going to be a really intense experience. But very worthwhile. Tonight I'll probably go out with the crew and chill, and tomorrow pack, charge various cameras and phones and iPods, and then go to church with the family before I don't see them for another 10 days. I love the excursions here.
This syllabus is kind of everything I could want to ever study and do: http://www.faculty.umb.edu/pjt/661b.html
I'm thinking it would be mad cool to do a TLS project at Bard on Community Epidemiology in this regard. I'd have to learn more about it first, ie why this ISP would be so important to me.
Today has been real bacana right now. I feel very at ease, very calm, and very ready for the world.
I also just ate copious amounts of acai for lunch, so I need to nap. Apparently thats very normal.
Wednesday, October 15, 2008
ISPPPPP
Below is my very rough brainstorm of what my TCR, Topical Critical Review, will look like. I have spent the majority of today-in between snacking on cupuaçu yogurt, watching youtube clips, and napping-doing research and taking notes on the plethora of sources I've been compiling and reading over the past few weeks here:
Begin with discussion of PSA, brief history and project aims. Next, discuss ecological public health [2 chapters, 1 overview of where public health is at and where needs to go, 1 on how it relates back to sustainability]) In the context of this new ecological public health under the umbrella of sustainability, how can communities and organizations avoid falling into the trap of the global commons? If ecological crises are formulated as global in nature, and therefore mandating global intervention, how can movements for sustainable health remain culturally autonomous and in the hands of the people? Explore Goldman/Escobar. Where do PSA fall in? From here, into the topic of whose knowledge is given precedence, and then go into Fischer and local knowledge. The system of development, in general, is one over the privileging of certain kinds of knowledge, science and technology, more Fischer on this. Go into At the Edge of Development, epidemiological transitions and state of health in
It's really rough, but tomorrow I am meeting with Gustavo to talk about it, and then I have all of Thursday night to get it done and write it out. Maybe I'll start tonight. Maybe. I'm pretty beat. But, I happen to really like the topic I am looking into. Part of the whole thing is that if I spend a month studying all about participatory community based development as it pertains to environmental health monitoring, it can give me a lot to bring back to the US and work with in terms of new ways to think about advocacy, a career, and how to provide empowerment working within culture to achieve the same ends. It's all about the means, after all. At the same time, the whole point of participatory epidemiology, popular epidemiology, or whatever you plan on calling it, is that it is intended to be understood and interpreted in the categories of that culture, so that the people living there within that particular logic are the best equipped to notice changes in health/environment patterns and make referrals based upon their own understandings of the world. I think the Edge of Development book I'm using, even though it's from the early 80's, put it nicely. Biomedicine needs to use the culture they are working with as an anchor, and then blend biomedical understandings of disease and technology to fit in with that reality. Otherwise, you are speaking in, more or less, two different "cultural languages". But as their studies also show, traditional health care has, by and large, been pretty receptive to biomedical advances when this cultural translation is made clear, and the benefits evident. As their main point states (although I'm sure I can see people take issue with the statement in terms of universalizing), the desire for health (defined in the broadest sense, physical, communal, familial, individual) transcends all cultural boundaries. It's not like you are dealing with some alien species here; we all are, after all, human. And since one's immediate community and environment are what matter most, I think it's a fair enough statement to make. Perhaps even by working with PSA, I could help in their project in whatever way I can, so that my status as a researcher also dissolves from the whole concept of a neutral, value-free, observer, to someone who is participating and collaborating with those he or she is working with.
"The physical environment, our habitat, is the most important determinant of human health. Protection of the environment and preservation of ecosystems are, in public health terms, the most fundamental steps in preventing human illness" (118).
Works for me.
This past week otherwise has been pretty uneventful. We were all pretty drained from Cirio Weekend. And it's somewhat still going on this week, minus the enormous procession. We had another Portuguese oral test, which I think I did fine on, judging by how the conversation went. Last night a few of us went out for sushi. I had a "Filadelfia Roll". It was cooked salmon and cream cheese in a roll. Needless to say, not as good as Philly-style. You also pump your wasabi in liquid half-soy-sauce form. But, it was cream cheese, which I miss, so, made me happy enough. I also decided to buy some new clothes yesterday, half because most of my shirts smell like boat-funk, and half because us Americans here in Brazil are experiencing Brazil's 50% off sale, as we like to joke, even though in reality it's terrible because the economy back home is dying, as you all know better than I. But still, it means you get a shirt here, which costs $R 30, but in U.S$ cost ~$13. Oh yeah.
Sunday, October 12, 2008
Nazare
This weekend was Cirio. Brazil's largest religious festival, here in Belem. The largest Catholic festival in the world. Slightly larger than the annual hadj to Mecca. Today, there were most likely 2 million people here just to celebrate nossa senhora da Nazare. A friend who lives right along the main street where the procession takes place was nice enough to let me stay at his family's apartment for two nights. Well, I should say the family was nice enough to let me stay there, as was Maura for being completely cool with me just sort of doing whatever all weekend and taking in all that Cirio has to offer. Cirio here to the Paraense is what Christmas is to the rest of Brazil. It's the time when your family flies from all over Brazil for one weekend. Saturday night the procession , consisting of the Virgin of Nazare "idol" and the thousands or millions of devote followers march from the Basilica da Nazare to the ingreja in Cidade Velha, the old part of the city. Then on Sunday morning, the same group marches with the Virgin back to the Basilica. Luckily for me, there is much to do over in Cidade Velha, so my weekend was incredibly interesting and engaging.
Thursday night, I took a break from working on Mini-ISP to go to this nice jazz club called Casa das Onze Janelas, which I went to during our first week in Belem. Instead of actually going into the club, Nigel, Sam, and myself all ran into each other, along with their respective host brother/sister, and ended up being in this huge party out in the plaza, complete with concerts, trying to talk in Portuguese, and so forth. Being here so far in Brazil, we have gotten to see and talk to so many different people, but haven't gotten any sort of feel for the everyday social life here, so it was a lot of fun to just let our guards down and be out and about. Friday night was more of the same. It's also just cool to experience someone else's host family, and how different each of our experiences here in Belem are. Especially with my family being Protestant and, well, everyone else's being Catholic.
Saturday I had another fun "Dan-takes-the-wrong-bus-several-time-and-then-tries-to-take-a-taxi-to-meet-up-with-people" experience. Talking with taxi drivers is pretty fun, and if you are friendly with them and actually try and have a conversation, at least here in Belem, they let a few reais slide by when it comes time to pay the bill. Almost as fun as trying to communicate to the person cutting your hair in a hair salon, but thats different. Much more frightening. When I actually managed to find people, we met up at the Praca da Republica for a giant Cirio festival-esque party. It ended up being this very large gay-pride festival that everyone else just kind of ends up going to, so it was pretty intense. It was hard to even walk around, but fun. Lots of street food, music, and crazy antics that, in Brazil, of course only happens during a large religious festival.
Today was the actual procession. It was insane! In an awesome way, as is everything in Brazil. Things tend to go to either extreme here. People don't seem to muddle around in the middle grey area. All or nothing, and it's a cool way to approach the world, I think. Needless to say, thousands upon thousands of people walking along the avenue, some walking for fun, some walking to have their prayers answered, and so on, was a very cool experience. Intense and somewhat overwhelming. But worthwhile. It makes me keep thinking how important religion is to people, and how much sometimes I wish I had that something to bring myself together with some sort of community. Quakerism was something along those lines, as was Buddhism back then a little ways. I've actually had a number of talks with people here, most on the boat trip, when all cool conversations happen, about what Quakerism is, what it means to me, etc, and made me really appreciate more what Westtown gave me, in that regard. I miss Quakerism a lot, sometimes, to be honest. Even if just for that community aspect.
This week we have a lot of down time to work on our ISP ideas more fully, so I will keep updating about that. We also have a lecture with IMAZON, the Amazonian environmental research institute, and I'm looking forward to that. I'll also try to post pictures of Cirio that my friends took.
Tchau, e boa noite
Thursday, October 9, 2008
I Love Goiaba

Speaking of Portuguese, I ended up acing my oral test, with the comment "sem pausas". Oh yeah.
So, putting that good language skill to the test, I've basically been sitting around with my host aunt Maura talking about everything in the world: what kinds of fruits are here in Belem, anthropology and community development, the Brazilian public health system, the obligation of people to pay pack to their communities, and so on. You know, typical Dan stuff. I live for it. She's a pretty amazing woman, she works as a doctor and a teacher of public health, so I'm gue
ssing the fact that I am living with her family is no coincidence. She finds anthropology to be really interesting as a medical person, someone who has to work within and with various cultures everyday, and we had a really cool conversation about the differences between anthropology in the U.S and in Brazil. In the U.S, we have anthropology, and applied anthropology. In Brazil, it's the same thing. In the U.S, it's hard for anthropology peeps to really do a lot in the public sphere, write in newspapers, make their opinions and thoughts widespread, affect public policy; in Brazil, they are all over the place, from writing in newspapers to working in government bureaus. She wants to take me to the Emilio Goedli Museum here in Belem sometime, that would be very cool.Today our Mini-ISP group got together at Neil's apartment to put our findings together. I'm going to be responsible for the conclusion of the paper, so tonight I need to write about what our main findings we
re, what the problems with our research was, and how these could be remedied in the future, and how the project could be built upon as a whole. That's kind of my thing, so it should be good. Our main objective was to see if ALCOA had an effect on health in the town of Juruti, so, obviously, we found that there was an affect on health care in the town. In general, although there were some contrasting opinions, the common thread was that the health care system had improved with the recent developmental boom due to ALCOA: hospitals had become more frequent, more clinics were being built, and there is now more access to doctors. Yet, at the same time, there aren't enough doctors to keep up with the population boom, nor are their enough specialized doctors. People also held doubts about who would benefit from ALCOA's promises and rewards to the town, and who would miss out. While the system had generally gotten somewhat better, overall health conditions had declined. With a high population that is quickly becoming more technically oriented comes more cars, more industry, and thus more contamination of common resources such as air and water. Many of my inform
ants spoke of the high frequency of respiratory problems from the recent heavy air pollution. Coupled onto this was the fact that in order to find any specialized doctor, such as someone to deal with all the lung concerns, one needs to travel to Santarem or Manaus. Thus, this lead to much distrust and dismissal of the medical professionals in the town. So, while there is more satisfaction with the health care system in Juruti, this is hampered by the disdain for the recent wave of health conditions brought about by the heavy development. To throw some numbers out there, from 2000 the town experienced a population boom from 14,000 people to 50,000 people. Most of our informants have only been in Juruti for a few months. Nevertheless, getting together to discuss the project was a cool experience. I had been a little wary about group dynamics when we started, but doing a qualitative project was so much easier in the end working with 4 other people. Just being able to bounce ideas off of each other and get suggestions for each of our sections made the whole thing less of a hassle. It also gives me some faith the qualitative is
the way to go, for me at least. To each his own, but I think its best to let people speak for themselves, such is the point of democracy in general.This weekend is Cirio, the world's largest Catholic festival in the world, held at the Basilica de Nazare here in Belem. Unfortunately, my family, ie Maura, is Protestant, so, they won't be doing anything. I will need to tag along with a friend for sure, I don't want to miss this, it is supposed to be an insane and awesome experience. The exchange rate is INSANE here right now, everything is so cheap. So, tomorrow is shopping for bad clothing day. There are so many strange t-shirts here with English that makes no sense. I also recently discovered that there is a supermarket close to my house, so, all I do is get goiaba juice. Goiaba=gauva=the most refreshing thin
g in the world, personally.Today, I went with Karina to grab lunch at the Bosque and stare at the bamboo everywhere. It's very cool, it is a mini-zoo, in a way, but it is great to grab lunch and go, look at the monkeys, the manatee (which is quite depressing actually), and walk around in. There's even a cave you can walk through and look at bats in. It's cool. One of the things about Belem I actually like. Then I proceeded to get ice cream across the road with Megan and Jacob before going to Neil's to work on the Mini-ISP. So, full circle. Tonight I need to write up my section and keep plugging along at the reading for my actual ISP. The more I talk about community based participatory environmental health, the more excited I get. There's a chapter in, Citizens, Experts, and the Environment, the book I mentioned about the concept of "popular epidemiology" that I can't wait to get to. Despite how boring and same-old-same-old life can feel once we are stuck in a schedule here in Belem, I feel more passionate about actually doing something with my life than I do at Bard. And thus why talking to Maura tonight was so cool, because it keeps coming up and coming up and coming up: I blame Robert Weston for making me obsessed with the "gift relationship". But it is everywhere! The whole book by Marcel Mauss, The Gift, is all about this one simple concept that one finds in everything from archaic society to modern states: I give, so that you give, and that the giving of a gift demands reciprocity. Simple but everywhere. I say hi to you, with some intent that the next time you see me, you will say hi too. If the structure of my society allows me to go off to college and study whatever I want while there are people who would take full advantage of the college experience but can't, then don't I have some obligation to return that, in some way? At least, that's what she seemed to think in reference to the Brazilian education system, but it holds the same water in the United States too.
There is so much to think about here.
Tuesday, October 7, 2008
Oh I Can Feel It
Well, I guess I can begin by telling you all that I feel content in knowing this whole experience is having a large affect on me, and I can feel myself changing, while at the same time getting to really know myself, and be quite comfortable with who I am. In talking to my closest friend here, we've been talking about how to sum up what had the biggest affect on us over the past few weeks, and that it is probably the more mundane little moments that have done the most. So, I guess I'll just try to tell a few stories the best I can.
In general, I spent a lot of time on a boat with 21 other students, most of the time doing nothing, which terrifies me. So, it was good to confront that, in a way, so I feel like that alone made the three weeks worth it. But it also was amazing just seeing things like the meeting of the waters on the left there. The meeting of the waters is probably one of the most mind blowing things I saw between Manaus and Belem. The Rio Negro, black water, and the Rio Solimoes, white water, come together near Manaus and drift side by side without really mixing for around 6 kilometers. We got to go swimming in it.
But I'm getting ahead of myself there. A week before getting on our 6 night boat trip, we each spent 4 day
I suppose coming into the whole experience I had a very academic-problem-oriented approach. I do so much reading for class on political economy structural analysis, basically looking at overarching political or econom
Coming back then, from being so immersed in my host family's everyday life, to being on a boat full of people, was an interesting transition, just as is being back in Belem right now. I felt very refreshed and renewed, which I can also say the same for my current state. From the rural homestay, we spent another night on boat number one, and spent the whole day just traveling back to N
and their medical hospital boat that travels along the Santarem region portion of the Amazon, providing much needed curative medical care to communities (they already have an incredibly successful preventative medical system in place with water treatment). I'm also somewhat in love with sleeping in a hammock. At night, having the wind whip around while the boat basically rocks you to sleep, is one of the more perfect experiences you can ask for. Plus, nothing beats the typical cup of coffee while you sit on the front on the boat, occasionally seeing river dolphins poke their spout out of the water.The boat itself was quite an experience. A lot of sitting around, reading, and reflecting. Not about things I can really put into words, but it was good for me as a whole. A lot of little conversations here and there as you stare out at the never ending waves or rows of trees you pass by. You end up taking a lot of time to just be by yourself,think, and s
tare out at sunsets and such. Some of my time just consisted of sitting on the back of the boat with a friend or two just talking about life, what
matters most to us, and where we see life taking us. It's little things like these that I think give you such a huge insight into life, or at least, into what drives us and makes us who we are. I think, perhaps, I finally somewhat get myself. Perhaps K put it well: I'm quite calm, but capable of large amounts of anger/passion/whatever you want to call it. I accept that I am quiet, and that I speak only when I feel I really need to, but that I am smart, and am articulate, and can embrace that and feel strong again.The rest of the trip for me consisted of several lectures I wasn't really that into, such as a lot of biogeochemical cycling that I don't quite understand. Lots of walking through forests. The other day, in looki
The past few nights have been really relaxing and fun, consisting of just walking around the city with a few friends, stopping in at bars, eating dinner, or just chatting while staring out at the stars and river. Good things. There's so much more that happened on this trip that I don't really know how to explain or put into words. Just little realizations and epiphanies here and there, some of which I think I've been able to explain, but others not. The other day, we met with a priest here in Santarem about the struggle against the soy giant, Cargill. He said something that has been on mind mind greatly: "This is what the system does, and you, you students, you need to come here, to Brazil, to see what that system does". For a while here I've been struggling with why exactly I am coming all the way down to Brazil as a gringo to work with disadvantaged communities when there is so much of that just close by in Philly. I know I want to do something like that in the US when I get back, maybe work with the Philly Hunger Project, or the American Red Cross, but at the same time, the world isn't isolated into local clusters. What we do up in PA or NY has direct affects that I am able to see here in Brazil. Last week we did our second Mini-ISP in the town of Juruti. Mine was focused on the topic of healthcare. Juruti, before 2000, was a small little town. In 2000, ALCOA, the American Aluminium giant, moved in to start mining operations, pushing thousands of people from access to former hunting/fishing grounds. The town experienced a huge population boom, brining more jobs and infrastructure to the region, but, also brought along increased industrial pressure, air poll
There is so much to be passionate about. On the bus to the FLONA forest, a bunch of us were talking about what we could see each other doing in the next couple years. I think my friend and I came to a conclusion about me that I feel is pretty accurate:
Right now, I feel that research for the sake or academia or just research isn't enough. This semester has shown me that I find anthropology/sociology to be very relevant and important, but, I don't think it should really be done on its own. I felt so uncomfortable just going up to people asking them about health in Juruti knowing that whatever I heard would be useless. Their time to answer some questions had no other point than to show a bunch of foreign students what the research project is like. I can't imagine doing fieldwork knowing that all the research I did would have very little effect to better the people in the community. All that might happen is I end up writing a clever and witty book on them. And while that might spur some sort of political action or consciousness, I don't think that is enough on its own right, something that Fischer points out is more of an overall problem of the social science tradition in general, but still applies to anthropological research. Most social sciences seem
When I was getting ready to leave for Brazil, the whole meeting of the waters thing was so far off, and now, its already happened. The whole vortex idea I mentioned earlier is working. I know it is, I can feel myself with a purpose now. Good bye being jaded. I feel stronger, in general, and it's cool. I feel like myself, or at least, the person I've always know is in me, but just takes sometime to come out. It feels so nice to feel so renewed, awakened. I can't even imagine how I will feel when I get back from ISP. But I imagine the answer to be "good", at the very least. SIT has been by no means perfect, and there has been plenty of ups and downs. But as an experience, it has been fantastic and mind-blowing, in a very subtle way. By the way, that picture there is of a beach we got to swim in on the middle of the river. So many amazing things, from big to mundane, happened on this trip. In one sense it is nice to be back in Belem and have some down time, but on another it is so nice to be in constant movement. I like this whole not being grounded thing, it is so liberating. Yes, that's the correct word for the past three weeks. Liberating.