If this excursion is anything like the past two we have had, it will prove me right. And seeing as this one looks even better than the last two, that is quite good. This program has already given me so much to think about in only 3 weeks that in that regard it is already worth it. I keep thinking back to some of the critiques I received at my moderation board, how I was swimming in too much high theory, paying too much attention to method, and not enough to just, well, what happens with people. The way most anthropology articles/books for that matter seem to be written nowadays is a structure like this:
- general broad theory used to frame the author's point of view/frame of the subject
- talk about methods/motivations
- use small snippets of quotes from informants, but in a way that supports the theory/objective of the author (like in any science for that matter)
- concludes with how the experience down at the ground level challenges/reshapes the above theory
That all said and done, I feel that is the most important thing right now. And even if this semester in Brazil has it's ups and downs, like anything else in life, I can pull away that I am learning that. I am learning what does indeed matter most. If I had to go back to the US right now, for some strange reason, I would be ok with that, because I feel like experiencing what I have already, and coming to those conclusions, has been worth the trip in and of itself. I've always been pretty good at learning to make the most of things that are in front of me. I feel like now, it is my job to go back home, and apply what I now feel, not know, to life at home, at Bard, and at those communities around me. I left the US feeling something along the lines of something anthropologist Nancy Scheper Hughes said in an interview, when the interviewer commented that it must take an enormous amount of courage to go off into a different land and interact with its people, etc. She replied, me roughly paraphrasing, "Well, I think what you call bravery is in fact a sort of struggle to belong. A lot of us instead have always somewhat felt that they don't quite belong in their own culture, or that it is missing something, so what you call courage I would call a search to find something that fits with you". A month ago, Brazil was my "escape" from life back in the US, from home, from academic life at Bard, from the general everyday grind. Brazil was the place, from what I had read and heard, that I could imagine myself belonging in, coming back to to work later in life, etc. I imagined it to be the place where I would find something that had been missing. Now I find myself realizing that what I've found in Brazil isn't any calling to Brazil or Amazonia in particular, but instead just the simple realization that in the end it is the people you care about that matter the most, and you don't need to work in Brazil, or Belem, or Amazonia, in order to help protect the communities you know are important to yourself, but maybe more importantly, to the people around you. And to me, that holds more meaning than any academic published paper or high level theorized conclusion. And that feels good to be at that place.
I realize maybe that half of that might not have made sense. Thats ok. I've been flipping through the Tao Te Ching once in a while at night while I listen to the music coming from outside, so I'd like to just share a quick little passage (everything in the book is short and cool), which maybe sums up my thoughts much easier than I have done:
"Do you want to improve the world?
I don't think it can be done.
The world is sacred.
It can't be improved.
If you tamper with it, you'll ruin it.
If you treat it like an object, you'll lose it.
There is a time for being ahead,
a time for being behind;
a time for being in motion,
a time for being at rest;
a time for being vigorous,
a time for being exhausted;
a time for being safe,
a time for being in danger.
The Master sees things as they are,
without trying to control them.
She lets them go their own way,
and resides at the center of the circle."
I think the whole journey in Manaus and Santarem, between the rural home stay experience where we will all be isolated and the 10 day boat trip, will very much force me, like this excerpt, to stop trying to control anything, and just let things take their course. As we flow along the river, maybe I'll also just learn to let things flow. I suppose rivers are the best place to do just that. Saude e alegria, here I come.
Yesterday I managed to barter in Ver-o-Peso market. I successfully lowered the price of a pair of shorts from 15 reais to 13 reais. Does it make me a typical Bard kid to see a connection between the anarchistic Joker persona in Dark Knight and the Tau Te Ching telling me to stop trying to control everything? Tonight, it's literally into o coração do Amazonia, the heart of the Amazon, so says my host family.

